What France Understands About Protest That America Doesn’t

Summer is simply a quiescent protestation play successful France, dissimilar the US. In France, protestation is woven into mundane life—people march betwixt errands, kids chant with sandwiches successful hand, and civic enactment is expected. In the U.S., wide enactment is rare, and buying is our nationalist pastime. If we privation existent change, possibly we request to halt swiping and commencement marching.

The archetypal clip I saw a protestation successful France, I thought idiosyncratic had died connected the bus. It was a Tuesday greeting successful Nantes, grey and wet, and the tram had stopped without warning.

The operator conscionable got retired and lit a cigarette.

No announcement, nary replacement bus. A assemblage started forming adjacent the préfecture, fractional of them waving signs, the different fractional just... watching.

Is this normal?

No 1 looked surprised. The different folks connected the autobus (and determination weren’t precise many) got up and walked disconnected the bus, mostly without comment.

That’s erstwhile it deed me: this was normal.

Weird.

Protest Lifestyle Choices

Protest is simply a weekday activity. People acceptable it betwixt java and childcare. Longer protests instrumentality breaks for lunch, they instrumentality evenings disconnected and spell home, past prime it up again the adjacent day.

Kids protest, too.

They cognize the chants. They battalion sandwiches. It’s not ever angry. Sometimes it’s festive. Sometimes it’s absurd. But it’s alive. Civic engagement present doesn’t conscionable mean voting each fewer years. It means showing up, blocking roads, banging pots astatine midnight.

Meanwhile, backmost successful the U.S., we amusement up much for the sales. We campy retired for Black Friday. We bash it each year.

Costco rotisserie chickens are divisive - the Costco blistery canine is simply a uniting contented (a large write-up of the $1.50 blistery dog’s multi-billion dollar impact).

Protests are rarer. Something we bash erstwhile things get really, truly bad—like constabulary murdering idiosyncratic connected camera. Otherwise, we grumble online and bargain noise-cancelling headphones.

It is acold from cleanable successful some places, but still: 1 state trains its citizens to march. The different trains them to swipe their cards.

If we privation alteration successful America, possibly we should halt buying and commencement learning the words to L’Internationale.

Numbers Don’t Lie

France Protests, America Shops

In France, protestation is portion of the civic landscape. The state sees dozens of organized demonstrations each month, and immoderate of the biggest tin gully much than 3 cardinal radical successful a azygous day.

In France, civic information successful thoroughfare protests is remarkably high. During the 2023 pension betterment demonstrations, betwixt 1.2 and 3.5 cardinal people joined marches crossed the country—nearly 5% of the population connected highest days. In aboriginal 2024, over 4,000 husbandman protests took spot crossed Europe, with France regularly seeing highways and metropolis centers unopen down by tractor convoys.

U.S. civic engagement tends to highest astir statesmanlike elections.

The 2020 statesmanlike predetermination had a 67% turnout, a beardown showing by American standards. France usually sees 72–80% elector turnout for statesmanlike elections.

Mass protests successful the U.S. are uncommon and often reactive. The George Floyd/BLM movement drew 15–26 cardinal radical implicit respective months, making it the largest successful U.S. history—still lone around 8% of the population, dispersed retired implicit a fewer months.

The 2017 Women’s March saw 3–5 cardinal globally, with astir 500,000 successful Washington, D.C.

Compare that to 131.7 cardinal Americans (almost 40%) who shopped connected Black Friday 2024, spending $10.8 billion successful 1 day. That’s a immense mobilization—just not for a governmental cause.

In France, protests are regular, organized, and portion of the taste script. In the U.S., they’re much exceptional—and erstwhile they scope French levels of turnout, it’s usually due to the fact that there’s a merchantability connected TVs.

It’s besides wherefore I accidental that to marque existent alteration successful the US, stop fucking shopping.

Summers

Summer slows France’s protestation machine—not for deficiency of outrage, but due to the fact that fractional the country’s connected vacation.

August is sacred. Unions pause. Even die-hards commercialized marches for pétanque.

Still, this month, determination were air-traffic strikes each implicit Europe. Pro-Palestine marches swelled. Anti–far close rallies flared aft the elections. Farmers brought tractors to the capital. Someone adjacent stormed the Tour de France decorativeness line.

Lighter, yes—but the fuse is ne'er excessively acold from the match.

By contrast, summertime successful the U.S. often ignites protest. With schools out, assemblage campuses quiet, and upwind connected their side, Americans are much apt to flood the streets successful June oregon July than successful January. The George Floyd protests began arsenic the vigor rose. Pride marches, termination rights rallies, migrant justness actions—they each spike during the summertime months, erstwhile outrage tin determination much freely outdoors.

There’s little structure, less unions guiding the schedule. But erstwhile thing breaks—another constabulary killing, a tribunal ruling, a governmental flashpoint—Americans march hard and fast. Unlike France, wherever protestation is simply a signifier of ongoing civic choreography, U.S. protestation civilization is much reactive, much combustible. The signifier isn’t steady—but erstwhile it erupts, it’s summertime that burns.

not lone number, but leverage

The American civilian rights marches weren’t monolithic by today’s numbers—250,000 astatine the 1963 March connected Washington, conscionable 25,000 arriving successful Montgomery aft days of walking from Selma—but they were meticulously planned, strategically staged, and aimed consecutive astatine the machinery of powerfulness for maximum outrage.

These weren’t spontaneous assemblage surges. They were coordinated acts of civic pressure, designed to extremity the scales of national law.

Hopefully, it is not simply however galore march—it’s where, when, and with what purpose.

protest doesn’t ever mean winning

And successful France, contempt the marches, the authorities often does what it wants anyway. Macron’s pension betterment was inactive pushed done without a vote, utilizing Article 49.3.

Perfectly legal. Deeply unpopular.

But successful France, protestation isn’t conscionable astir winning. It’s astir being seen, creating pressure, and refusing silence.

Even the monolithic Gillet Jaunes movement’s deeper demands didn’t materialize. Many protesters felt co-opted oregon burned out. The question fragmented implicit time.

They won immoderate argumentation shifts. But the large fight—for dignity, visibility, and fairer economics—remains unresolved.

Ever marched successful a protest? Or skipped 1 to deed a sale?
I’d emotion to perceive however civic beingness feels wherever you are.
What makes radical amusement up—or enactment home?

Leave a comment

Introducing Contributor, Keith Christiansen

Immerse yourself successful each of Keith’s articles→